Showing posts with label writing tools. Show all posts
Showing posts with label writing tools. Show all posts

Friday, March 1, 2013

Markup for iPad: Paperless Feedback on Writing

One role of the ELA teacher that will probably not change any time soon is the "marker-up" of writing.  I learned long ago that there is little profit gained from close editing of student work, pre or post grading; students may or may not make the indicated changes, but they will definitely make the same errors over and over again if the teacher indicates the fix every time (as shown in the sample below).

On the other hand, students do learn from close editing the work of another, be this a fellow student's or a "bad model" text.  And teacher or peer comments on the ideas, text structures, arguments, evidence and discussions in student work - both good and needing improvement - definitely do result in improved writing.  A quick, fluent feedback stream is essential.

In the early days of a laptop program I used NoteShare extensively to these ends. This versatile Mac app (we used NoteShare Server) was the mainstay of my literacy program.  In today's iPad classrooms, teachers have to work a little harder to achieve a paperless feedback stream.  There are, however, some useful tools to consider.

First, consider adding $1.00 or more to the KickStart of Markup for iPad.  Created by the smart folk that brought us ShowMe, this is an app with a single purpose.  19 days to go, and counting, as of March 1, 2013.  It would be a shame if this development were stalled.  1000 teacher pledges would go a long way.


How will the app work?  Student essays or other text is uploaded to a cloud space (DropBox would be perfect for this but email is also a possibility to be considered), annotated or marked up using a stylus right on the teacher iPad, then returned to the student the way it came.  Short and sweet.  It does not require that student and teacher be on the same wifi.  And it can also be used for student-to-student and distance collaborations on any text.  
This is probably as simple as it is going to get for a while.  Here are a few more complex solutions:
  • Pages itself does a good job of allowing for in-text markup, including a track changes function.  Not my favorite method, but it would work.  Use Share and Print, then Open in Another App to save as a .pdf file.  Your school may also have a Mac OS X Server with a WebDAV server, make transfer of files through the network easy.  
  • GoodReader does a great job with .pdf files, allowing multiple types of markup both with and without a stylus.  Hints:
    • Have students write in Pages, Word, or other editor then convert (export or share) to .pdf before uploading to DropBox, etc.  Student retains the original to compare with the annotated version.
    • Do NOT save annotations on a page until you are done!
    • Using GoodReader in connection with a class Google Docs / Drive (with or without Blog Docs app) account will allow students to quickly view the marked up copy sent from Google Docs
  • Google Docs or Google Drive can be used to annotate as well, but not with a stylus. I don't know about you, but I find quick editing much easier with a stylus than with the iPad keyboard.  Good tutorials for this can be found all over the web, but start with this guide to Google Drive for the iPad.
  • Penultimate is a neat tool for student hand-written work, perhaps practice for SA questions on a local or state test.  "Notes" can be titles then mailed to a DropBox, GoDocs, Evernote or Google Docs folder.
Final word:  Support Markup for iPad so that the best tool will be available before the end of this school year (and you might get a free t-shirt too).

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Writing/Thinking Smarter Tools: Beyond the Blueprint

source (not my cabin)
Jump down to the SCAN review.

I've just come in from inspecting a cabin we are building in the woods. The two young builders -  bright young guys who work for Morse and Doak - wanted to show us a problem area. Seems we have three walls on the 1-room central tower that a challenge to finish. One corner cantilevers out over the great room, one cantilevers out over the bedroom wing hall, and a 3rd continues the stairwell wall into the room.  What did we want to do to finish each so it doesn't grate visually against the other walls and spaces?  Great question.  I never knew it was a question until today.  I never thought about how many ways there are to finish a wall.  I never thought about how much math there is in building a frame cabin.  Granted, it is not a simple design.  When an "organic designer" draws up the plans, there are going to be complexities. 

"We have so many ideas," grinned Darius, "so many ways to solve the problems. A lot of crazy ideas just crashing around." As we discussed the ideas, he and Lonnie explained the pros and cons of each.  In the process, they had two or three more ideas.  The energy surging between the two ladders to the 2nd floor was palpable.  Their solutions were inventive, each firmly founded on knowledge of the topic (generally, boards and measurements) and the problem.  These weren't, in fact, crazy ideas at all.  What was crazy to Darius was the shear number of ideas he generated in response to the problem.   

I was lost.  I said, "I leave it up to you - just make what you are thinking and doing clear to me."  And they did, translating what they know into language I could follow, providing evidence to support the options they recommended, clarifying counter-proposals.  We made an action plan.

The experience got me thinking about thinking. All kids think - but isn't Darius and Lonnie-type thinking what we want kids to do?  Isn't this how we want our kids to approach learning problems?  Granted, my builders are highly trained and highly experienced. But they are also always thinking.  And they think smart - beyond the blueprint. 

ELA connection:  For the ELA classroom, the challenges focus mainly on thinking and writing about text and on the process of persuasion.

There are writing workshop models, writing curricula, reading workshop models, and reading curricula. But what it comes down to is this: You can not write well about anything unless you can think well about it.  And writing well carries a high premium - for both students and teachers.

It goes without saying, and is outside the scope of this post, that you can not think well about "it" if you can not read well about it.  Darius and Lonnie have skills I do not have: they can read blueprints and wood.  Presumably, our students come to us with the skills they need to access the information they need by reading.  Huge supposition - and often not true - but the essential question for this post is:  What can we do to help student DO something smarter with what they read?  Whether the challenge is to analyze or to persuade, What can we do to help them think?

Heather Wolpert-Gawron argues that all writing about text is persuasive writing.  I find this a clarifying idea. It means that all thinking about text - whether fictional or informational - is framed by the goal of persuasion.  It means that the essay can be re-imaged as a forum for convincing the reader.  This adds a vital dimension to writing - connection.  And connection leads to the need for: voice, style, evidence, explanation.  I have always known this to be true of good writing, but now I understand what makes it true.  My favorite motivational turn of phrase, Writing is problem-solving,  remains true also. The two concepts work hand-in-hand.

Read/Think then Write/Think.  You notice that in the above image Share is also embedded in the writing process. As my builders demonstrated, discussion extends and clarifies thinking. On the other hand, reading and idea-forming are highly individual activities. The best processes for writing require both individual and collaborative thought.

A last point.  It is essential that students push the write/think connection all the way to the level of what Randy Rambo calls The Warrant.  This is the step that involves explicitly making  the connection between the claim (point, opinion) and the evidence used to support it.  Some teachers call it the discussion or explanation.  I call it the So what? Why is this important?  Omitting this step is the most common flaw in middle and high school writing. The second most common flaw is insufficient or irrelevant evidence.  Most tools put a premium on having evidence, but few require students to evaluate it. Good, solid evidence-gathering is essential for any academic writing task.  Beginning as young as 1st grade, students should be asked to provide information to support their opinion statements.  Sloppy thinking habits begin with low expectations.  


The tools: Luckily, there are tools for education that help our kids to learn to think, to love new problems as much as Darius and Lonnie do, and to organize their thinking for writing.  Here is a short list of those I consider to be the best.

  • SCAN is a brand new online interactive tool for "arguing" - I think it is a powerful tool for thinking.  Imagine a RAFT activity that grows organically, one in which all of the roles interact OR in which one student can explore all of the roles.  I was so interested in this model that I created a SCAN session for teachers and students to use collaboratively.  Here is the link to Should We Cancel Halloween?   Please contribute - it is a public discussion. I believe that it is possible to use the SCAN tool to investigate a novel-based thesis.  You might, for example, explore violence, trust, or individual v. society in any dystopian novel.  Roles can be characters or roles can be points of view.  It seems to me this is a highly adaptable tool that ELA teachers should embrace.  I used the free tool; teachers and schools can get larger functionality by paying a reasonable subscription fee.
  • ReadWriteThink online tools include Persuasion Map and the Webbing Tool.  The webbing tool can easily be used to construct a paragraph or an essay.  Their Essay Map does not contain the warrant or discussion step, so don't use it.
  • Not all students think best in bubbles. Some prefer a linear or outline organizer.  Unfortunately, I could not find a solid organizer that includes the warrant.  I did find this neat little organizer that can be used for every claim and easily extended.   Students can also use the interactive Thesis Builder to begin the process of developing an outline. The outline generated by the tool can be used as a model for the creation of a blank paper outline.  It would be interesting to use this tool with a group. 
  • Practical idea for the classroom:  We all know what Word Walls are.  The Phrase Wall is a similar concept.  Few students have internalized the transition, connection, and rhetorical phrases that help them to truly write/think about and through a text.  Refer to the Wall when oral thinking is happening in the classroom.  A large visual of the phrases that can (and should) be used in writing is not a crutch - it is a necessity.  Add to the Wall as writing becomes more challenging. I find it most useful to put Phrase Wall phrases into categories:
    • ordering phrases - first, second, in conclusion - (not recommended for final drafts, but very useful when drafting - have students use them then take them out)
    • linking phrases - another, also, furthermore, in addition to...., moreover, etc.
    • change of direction phrases - however, on the other hand, but not, etc.
    • rebuttal phrases (specifically for "the nod to the opposition") - it can be argued that, evidence also points to..., etc.
    • idea starter phrases - consider..., an important/the most important..., etc.
    • evidence phrases - according to..., when [this happens]...[this happens], etc.  
    • warrant phrases - ______ is saying that, if this is true then..., this leads to..., by
    • comparing, as a result..., because..., etc.
    • conclusion phrases - it is clear that, clearly,  (these can also often be removed)
  • Thinking in the classroom: Activity tools.  Just talking is easy for adults, but not easy for children. It is a good idea to embed deeper thinking about a topic, text, or question in a short activity.  These activities are also valuable as stand-alones to develop thinking skills and language. Some ideas:
    • "body voting" followed by "build on someone" statements of opinion, evidence, or explanation
    • "fish bowl" discussions in which evidence must be presented and evaluated, discussed - here is a nice guide
    • "hot seat" in which evidence is used to question a character or role-player
    • "easel pad" discussions - evidence is displayed on large pages - groups move round the room adding explanation or discussion statements
    • "silent conversations" - small groups tackle a topic or thesis, not speaking but writing and adding to the point of the previous writer - can be done in roles 
    • Last point: In using any group tool, it is important to set the guideline that every student must participate.  No passes on thinking.
       

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Drop By: Dropbox and Connected Apps

I use Edublogs.org to host my other commentary blog, U & D, a holdover from experimenting with it as a host for individual student blogs (worked well and I recommend it).  Because it has a teacher-centered mission, Edublogs provides support and training beyond just hosting.  The Free Tools Challenge makes available step-by-step tutorials for online tools that support classroom learning, student creativity, and collaboration.  There are other tutorial sites and other tools - I like Richard Byrne's Google Tools collection at Free Technology for Teachers and Kathy Schrock's Kaffeeklatsch.

But I am especially excited about Free Tools Challenge #17.

DROPBox and DROPitTO.me are management tools  - specifically, tools for digital file submission, storing, and sharing.  Using them together is great for final drafts and big projects.  These are cloud tools, accessing a web-based storage and distribution system that synchronizes seamlessly with apps on digital devices.

The DropBox app is fully cross-platform and cross-device: Mac, Windows, Linux, mobile (iPhone, iPad, Android, Blackberry).  You will need the app on each tool you will use to receive, upload, and download files sent to you by others (or that you want to send to yourself).  These are free downloads.

submission interface
DROPitTO.me is a web-based upload service.  Here is the big picture:
  • you set up your DropBox app and account once - if you have not done so, do it online
  • with that account open, you go to DROPitTO.me and set up a submission account with two passwords: one for your only (administration) and one for everyone else (submission)
  • you get a unique URL for DROPitTO.me - this will use the login your specify (my login is eskymac: dropitto.me/eskymac is the URL)
  • you send this URL and the submission password to students - or post them somewhere - you can even use QR code for this (put it on an assignment, website, or a poster in your classroom)
  • students upload files into a folder called DROPitTOme within your DROPbox (this folder is created automatically) using the web submission interface (above)
  • you access these files on all devices that have the DROPbox app
  • there does not seem to be a limit to the types of files uploaded - but there is currently a 75MB file size limit (huge)
Get a great set of directions at Free Tools Challenge #17.

Caveats:
  1. The capitals in the app names are really annoying - you don't need to use them to access the site or to locate the app in iTunes/AppStore.
  2. Yes, you open up a file space for students to send you viruses and other nasty content. Since nothing comes with a "from" you will not know who put it there.
  3. It is NOT yet possible to upload a file from an iPhone or iPad to DROPitTO.me, via Safari.  Apple locks the upload feature for the most part - works only for apps like Facebook, Twitter, Evernote, Dropbox - and at times is limited to photos and images. In fact, it seems that unless you want to jailbreak Safari Mobile, students are stuck uploading from desktop devices.  I hope this will be changed in the future.  That means that students will still need to use e-mail or a different app (see below) if the files have been created on a mobile device. 
  4. There are some concerns about the security of files - if you are concerned about this, use an in-network file transfer, which you can actually complete over wifi, or use email.
  5. This is not a 2-way street.  You can not return corrected files through your Dropbox. 
  6. However, you can share folders using controls in the computer app and online (not on mobile device though) versions of your Dropbox.  This creates a 2-way street. So, you can share the DROPitTOme folder with students, or share a folder within that folder (you will need to manage this a bit).
  7. And there is no reason why you can not flip the ownership - students can install Dropbox on their own mobile devices, create and share folders with you. 
  8. Students with iPhones and other mobile devices CAN upload photos/images and videos to their own Dropbox folders.  Once this has been done, students can email the photos to you or move them into a file folder that you have shared.  Or share their folders with you, in which case you see the folder in your Dropbox. Sounds complicated, but once you try it, it is very quick.  Does not work with other file formats yet (Pages or Keynote documents, for example).
Other solutions:  These apps work to send content to the specified Dropbox account - which would probably be yours.  So they are useful to you as a teacher when you share the folders they create.  Sharing subfolders will give you a measure of security.


  • DropVox is an app that uses the built-in mic on the iPad and iPhone (probably also Android and Blackberry devices, but I can't check that) to create audio files that are automatically uploaded to the linked DropBox account - a DropVox folder is created.  This is another great way to receive and share audio within a class.
  • Drop It is an app that uses the "Select - Save" touch controls on the iPhone or iPad to send URL's to the linked DropBox account, directly to a folder called URLs.
  • Drop It! (confusing name choice) accesses your iPhone or iPad photo library and simplifies the process of uploading photos and images to the linked Dropbox account - or you can use the camera from directly within the app (Note: this is an iPhone app, but it works on the iPad too).
  • Textforce is an app that uses DropBox for collaborative .txt (text) writing.  Read about its features here and also here.  It is possible to create a document on an iPad, continue it on an iPhone, and finish it on a laptop.  Textforce accepts copy/paste also, which makes it easy to share files for the purpose of editing or annotation.  Caveat: this is Plain Text - which is also the name of the folder it creates in your Dropbox.  There will be minimal text formatting. Some formatting is available using its onboard tools.  The nice aspect of Textforce is that a file is opened within Dropbox, so downloading is not necessary.  Students could easily submit writing this way!
  • Videodropper is a web-based free tool for sending YouTube video to your Dropbox.  All you need is to allow access to your Dropbox acct, then copy/paste the YouTube URL.  This downloads the video, not the URL.
  • GoodReader is an iPad app that sees your DropBox folder (on a Mac on the same wifi) as a server - you can upload directly into the .pdf reader, annotate text, and return the annotated version to the student while saving the original
  • By the way, you CAN have two Dropbox accounts simultaneously on one Mac - but to do it, you need to tweak the command line code in Terminal.  Directions.  Try it if you dare. 

    If you want to try it: I suggest doing so with a few students, as trial runs.  A few experts and simple directions are all you will need to use Dropbox effectively in your classroom.