Showing posts with label reading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reading. Show all posts

Sunday, April 21, 2013

Why NOT to Read Using an Interactive App

Interactive is a buzzword.  Be careful, fellow teachers, how you employ it in the ELA classroom. 

It sounds like a great idea: apps that take on "the challenge of ensuring that every student is meaningfully moving forward in a given reading assignment—and not just faking it." (SLJ Reviews Gobstopper and Subtext).  The two interactive ebook reading apps reviewed by SLJ  work like the Kindle app on fire, or better yet, Kindle mated with Nearpod.  

Subtext
As shown in the screen shots, teachers can embed annotations, quizzes, blog-type discussions, tags, links (to rich media/video and web pages), underlining, and highlighting into the text the students read.  The purposes are to keep the students focused on the task of reading, to direct and enrich their reading with materials provided by the teacher, and to align these to the CCSS - all by layering discussions, tags, links, rich-media, annotations, and highlighting on top of the text. 

Gobstopper - showing video of teacher embedded
Maybe it's just me, but this seems to fly in the face of current trends to make students responsible for their own learning. It seems, in fact, to be exactly the same teaching philosophy that resulted in the reading packets and book-based websites much criticized now as the core of poor ELA teaching.  Gobstopper unabashedly offers "Curriculets" for the titles they provide for download (not too many titles yet, by the way, but many CCSS classics are there) which are really "fully baked" curriculum packets for the teacher, and Subtext allows the teacher to access embedded materials provided by other teachers.  Both will save teacher-generated media for the life of the app. It's a filing cabinet or laptop folder of printables in a 21st Century costume.   

The difference is that there is an attempt here, at least in Subtext, to engage students in a social media type discussion of text, which can now happen online or in-app rather than in the classroom.  Given this difference, and the wider text selection, I would vote for Subtext over Gobstopper.  Actually, I would never send serious students to a web app named after a revolting form of candy.  It leads me to wonder about the seriousness of the app's creators.  It certainly says something about their low opinion of the American student.

For the student, using either app is much easier than independent or worksheet-guided reading - one-stop shopping and no original thought needed. When you enter your classroom, you will know exactly what the teacher wants you to think about - or think. No need to open a blog or wiki or webpage or Edmodo.  No need to speak up in class.  No real reason for class.

For the teacher, using either app is much easier, after the initial effort to create or select embeddable content, than duplicating reading guides, making a website, or turning personal annotations into discussion guides to use in class. Gobstopper users can simply use the canned Curriculet. Subtext users can, if they wish, use the embedded questions and annotations of others - or lurk and copy these. The quizzes in both apps are self-graded reading checks (we used to call these "checks for understanding," but now they are just checks for reading) and the discussions are digital and archived, so the teacher can review them or just check off a participation grade. I would guess that not too many teachers will take part in the discussions - that would be too much like grading.  

It used to be that a student had ultimate reading choice; she could choose NOT to read or NOT to read deeply or NOT to think about the reading.  Grades probably were effected, but that student survived ELA, often by listening, sometimes by using cheat notes, and usually with an understanding that NOT doing had a negative consequence (which she may or may not have cared about...).  Her teacher had to work harder to engage teach that child (I am assuming that he does care, although that is surely not always true). Both student and teacher profited from this extra effort.  

Unless higher education has changed dramatically since my days, the college student still has the choice NOT to read or NOT to read deeply or NOT to think about the reading.  

We used to prepare students for the consequences of those critical decisions.  That was part of teaching independently responsible learning.  These interactive apps take away the opportunity to make reading choices.  In fact, I think they make it possible for a student to believe she is reading just because she responds to all of the layered-in objects.  In fact, I read p. 3 of Gatsby entirely by clicking the icons.  I would, I think, have been a star in the class the next day.

And for what gain?  Surely not for increasing a love of literature.  Take another look at the screen shots above.  Would you be able to really read Gatsby with all of that highlighting, underlining, iconography and pop-ups on your screen?  This may be the single worst way imaginable of guiding students into a love of literature and language.  

Not to mention the time it will take students to complete an assignment (Gobstopper recommends two chapters of Gatsby as an assignment length). Reading as a student, I got through about four interactive pages before I had enough.  Tired of interruptions.  Tired of taking part in discussions.  Tired of pointless quiz questions.  And I wasn't even reading with 25 other students.  

What I ended up doing was selecting two neglected sentences and writing disruptive annotations for others to discuss.  And I had no idea what was going on in the novel - a novel I love and have read non-interactively at least four times.  

Interactive is a buzzword.  Be careful, fellow teachers, how you employ it in the ELA classroom.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Myth #7: Digital Learning Develops Problem-Solving

8 Myths About Digital Learning

OK - I have to compromise on this one. I do believe that using digital tools develops the problem-solving skills necessary to use "new" digital tools.  In fact, I suspect that the thinking that leads children to succeed in any problem-solving digital game becomes a habit of mind that helps in solving similar non-digital, real-life problems.  Students who can, for example, advance steadily in Cut the Rope are more likely to be able make suggestions to get a team over a wall challenge or are more likely to contribute key language to a class constitution.

Here are some problem-solving basics (this is my own list):

  • I have to understand the problem and what makes it hard
  • I have to think about what I already "know" about the problem topic
  • I have to take a deep breath and think critically about what I read, see, think, feel, hear, and already "know" - throw out the unimportant, wrong, false, exaggerated, emotional, and biased
  • If I don't see a solution, I have to take a risk and try something different
  • If I do nothing, there will be no solution
  • I have to accept and learn from my mistakes, missteps, and failures
  • I have to give this time
  • If I find a solution right away, this doesn't mean I have the best solution
  • Some problems are too hard for just me
  • Being in a team has advantages, so listen to team members
  • Finding, keeping, and evaluating evidence and experience as I work for a solution is important
  • I have to test my solution (unless it obviously works)
  • Solving a hard problem gets me ready for an even harder problem and makes me better at similar problems
Problem-solving requires Critical Thinking. In education, Critical Thinking is today thought of as, well, critical.  As expressed in this post from Educational Technology and Mobile Learning, it has these elements:

Other researchers use different terminology for critical thinking skills:
It's In the Genes
Whichever language you choose, notice that individual judgment and opinion are embedded in these research models of Critical Thinking (on this point I quibble with critical thinking as applied by the Common Core to reading.  Personal response and previous knowledge matter. Enough said).  Note also that research supports that critical thinking skills can be taught, but also that once learned, they are not applied with automaticity by any individual.  Their optimum application in the classroom should, therefore, be monitored, and must be required.

The above research article (It's In the Genes) also states that problem-solving style preferences are innate (adaptive/narrow solution focused or innovative/wide solution focused).  This suggests to me that the design of an educational problem is, for many students, directly related to its outcomes - for an individual student and for a problem-solving team.  This requires a teacher or teaching team.

[Aside: the relationship between Problem-solving and Critical Thinking is a complex one, characterized by overlap and interdependence.  I have found this article to be very helpful in understanding the components of both as they related to education.]

So what?  It is clear to me that the skills of critical thinking can be assisted by digital tools, and to this degree digital learning does develop them.  Multiple cases have been made for the use of technology to enhance and develop each of the elements of critical thinking identified above.  Tools such as blogging and backchanneling can even develop the student's ability to self-examine and self-correct.

On the other hand, problem-solving is not developed, but supported, by technology. Ready access to information, including that previously explored and that converted to knowledge, and the communication of solutions and their analysis, are more easily done with facile use of technology than without.  But it only through solving problems that we get better at solving problems.  Ready access to multiple challenging problems may be better for students than extended access to one large, hard technology-rich problem.

So, when we speak of learning, we do better to speak of Critical Thinking.  When we speak of gathering and demonstrating learning - of the processes of learning (writing, reading, researching) - we do better to speak of solving problems.

I have touched on this previously:

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Two Literate Responses to the Common Core ELA

brain pickings
Fiction - Creative Nonfiction - Literary Nonfiction - Informational Text.  I am talking here about print text, not about genre or content or paper v. digital publication.  In a k12 environment of interactive digital text, audio text, visual texts and audio-visual texts, in a k12 environment of the supremacy of engagement, in a k12 environment where "fun lessons" are more sought after than challenging or deep-understanding lessons, in a k12 environment increasingly integrated with mobile digital tools, in a k12 environment increasingly pressured (despite the previous list) to approach text with analysis and rigor, what is a teacher to do?

I find confusion everywhere.  It is a fact that hard texts are not as much fun as easy or just right texts.  Should this change the curricular content of the ELA classroom?  On the one hand, it seems a student-centered thing to do.  On the other hand, the Common Core lays out a rigorous reading platform that does not seem much in step with lit circles and choice reading - much less with differentiation.

ELA teachers who wrestle with this at any level would do well take a deep breath and think about reading.  Do the prevalence of internet and digital texts mean that the nature of how we read must change?  There is a lot of talk about this, but not, I believe, much new pedagogy beyond that centering on the reading of informational text.  A lot of talk, a lot of commentary, most of which revolves around engagement, social media and attention span, but not much new pedagogy.

How we read text is not changing and will not change.  The options for non-text and extended-text reading are growing and changing.  That is a good thing.  But it does not mean that plain old reading of text - or the publication of just plain text - needs to change.

I think all ELA teachers should read the two articles below.  Both make the case for reading as a powerful and personal sense-making, creation-making...what?  Exercise. Mechanism. Tool.  Pleasure.  No matter.  What matters is that k12 kids become adult readers of text.  That is a goal of the Common Core, after all.

  • How We Will Read: Maria Popova - only one post in a series of interviews called How We Will Read (you can quickly access all of the posts here). Steven Johnson asks the same questions of each interviewee.  I suggest you read this post deeply then browse through others, following one question across several responders.
  • How to Talk About Books You Haven't Read - brain pickings - this is a literate review by Maria Popova of a book by Pierre Bayard.  

Read these articles for insights into how reading is done, encouraged, offered and approached in your classroom. Creating pleasure for a k12 child is often not about bells and whistles, but about attitude.

A dividend for the teacher who undertakes my exercise is this: it is an exercise in comparing texts and following threads.  Something we better know how to do because we expect our students to do the same.

Saturday, March 3, 2012

Reading on the iPad: 6 Elements of Instruction APP'd

[See this article in visual form]

[See also Only 1 iPad in the Classroom?  All of those apps and ideas will apply to a 1:1 iPad classroom.]

The March 2012 issue of Educational Leadership (Reading: The Core Skill) contains an article that all ELA and literacy teachers must read:  "Every Child, Every Day" by Richard L. Allington and Rachael E. Gabriel.   I don't know how long and to whom the article will be available, so I will capture the key points here.  What you need to read the article for, in addition to these key points, are the concise summaries of the research and literature about effective reading instruction.  It is a mini-guide to what should be happening in schools.

What I am going to do is to apply the six elements of instruction identified by Allington and Gabriel to reading with - or on - the iPad.  Whether today's teachers have one iPad for individual instruction, a 1:1 program, or something in between, it is important for them to understand the power of using this tool to support reading in the classroom.  (It is equally powerful, perhaps even more powerful, as a tool to support reading outside of the classroom).

First and foremost, Allington and Gabriel are talking k-12 and they are talking about what Allington elsewhere calls thoughtful reading across the curriculum.  The iPad is, of course, an across the curriculum tool, but it is also a powerful thinking tool.

Second, all of what is discussed here applies to both fiction and informational text (and in many cases to visual and auditory text).  Last, it is important to keep in mind Allington's response to the question, What is Reading?  In the linked-to interview he makes the point that when one is reading, there is a response: goosebumps, giggles, sorrow, anger, wonder...   These responses = media + motion.  We are in iPad country.

To best use the iPad for reading instruction, you will want, as a teacher, to have access to at least one measure of student reading level (F&P, lexile range, grade level equivalent). It is possible to find book lists (online and in print) to match any range. Just ask your librarian or literacy specialist. If this is what you rely upon, go that route and set up your iPads accordingly.

You can, for example, make folders on the Home screen of interactive texts for different ranges, for individual students, or you can make a Home icon link (easy to do on the iPad - see the screen shot) to a website on which are listed available or suggested titles.  Using Box or DropBox (slightly more complex), you can create web-based folders of texts differentiated for specific students, reading levels, reading interests, or reading groups.  These can be accessed directly from the iPad app.  This can be done by multiple teachers, all accessing the same folder (how cool would that be!). 

And you can, of course, load onto the iPad individually purchased titles, e-Books (Overdrive Media Console has an app - if your public or school library has the e-Book service, your students can "borrow" books right from the iPad). 

The 6 Elements of Instruction applied to the iPad:

1. Every child reads something he or she chooses - not all of the time or every time, but at some time during the school day. How many texts can the iPad hold?  It's infinite, if you consider the web as a text and the possibilities of borrowed e-Books and e-Texts.  Definitely thousands.  The iPad is an e-Reader.  It is an interactive e-Reader.  It can read to you.  You can read to it.  The iPad remembers your place (a good thing if multiple students are reading different titles, which is the goal) and remembers your annotations and bookmarks.  Wondering about this approach to reading?  Read this perspective.

Here are the best apps for digital reading Choice:
  • Kindle books are one choice.  Set up an Amazon account (password protected and do not save credit card information) and register as many iPads as you want.  Download purchased books from Amazon's Accounts interface or through a desktop/laptop.  Kindle books are often less expensive than print counterparts. Free and inexpensive classic texts, and daily $.99 specials, are also available. Books obtained via Amazon appear in the Kindle app Home menu, making them easy to access. 
  • iBooks (public domain titles, including many fairy tales and illustrated classics) is another way to store and access books.  Because it reads the ePub and .pdf formats, teachers can even upload texts that they create themselves.  
  • Storia is Scholastic's venture into iPad-land.  The e-Reader will offer titles from the Scholastic catalog, about 10% of which have been "enriched" to create an interactive experience.  Purchase prices will vary (compare to Amazon). Also keep in mind that titles sold by Scholastic, especially tween and YA titles, have been screened and may have been edited.  With 5 free books per download, you might consider downloading the app individually in order to differentiate purchases.  
  • Individual interactive book apps such as The Artifacts and numerous titles for elementary students can be purchased via the iTunes store/ iPad App Store (Books and Education are key categories, or you can search). Teachers need to create the account and keep the password secret from students. If the first download onto an iPad is a free app, a credit card does not have to be attached to the account.  Create folders on the Home screen to hold books in categories that work for you: subjects, grade level, individual students (each app can go into only one folder).
  • Comics and graphic novels (Comics app) - purchase titles online at ComiXology and download them to this iPad app - best for middle and high school. Purchase requires an online account.
  • Poetry from the Poetry Foundation serves up great poetry from the archive, by random shake or spin or by loose topic organization.  Many poems have voice recordings.  Free.
  • MegaReader 2.5 indexes and downloads free texts from sources such as Gutenberg and Feedbooks.  Young Reader is for elementary and middle school readers - it comes preloaded with over 130 public domain classics so texts can be read without wifi access.  Although a main purpose of Young Reader is to increase reading speed, it is also just a simple source of good texts at a wide range of levels.  Caution: some students will be frustrated by the bizarre characters that appear due to format conversions, so check out any titles you install.
  • OverDrive Media Console will connect students having library cards to public or school libraries with a e-Book loan service.
  • Newsstand - purchase some magazine subscriptions for your students.
  • Timbuktu - an app that aggregates a different upper elementary magazine (from multiple multi-media sources) weekly.  This is a multifaceted, multimedia reading experience.
  • Zite - an app that aggregates current articles by topic - great for middle and high school students who have very specific interests.
  • The Google App contains a News application.  Combined with Readability (see below), it supports choice as well as good options. 
  • The web - you can make a Home screen link to your own pre-selected web sites (see above) or to digital, web-based texts (you can even make your own web-page full of text... )  Science, history, sports...  Students can have individualized choice links on individualized pages or can download .pdf files created by the teacher (see #2 and #3 below for readers).
  • And don't neglect content specific apps that contain reading text!  Many science and social studies/history apps contain informational text.  Placing them into Home screen folders is a good idea.
Readability
2.  Every child reads accurately.  We have to infer what reading accurately means (those of us not deeply versed in Allington), but it is clear that, where meaning is the message,  "just right" texts must be available in sufficient variety and number that choice can be right for every child in school, in every content area, during the school day.  But Allington and Gabriel note, "Sadly, struggling readers typically encounter a steady diet of too-challenging texts throughout the school day as they make their way through classes that present grade-level material hour after hour. In essence, traditional instructional practices widen the gap between readers."   Even in the best of school situations, all day is probably not possible, and, unfortunately, the Lexile.com tool for measuring the difficulty of an input-text selection is not available as a mobile app (it should be), so judging text appropriateness on the fly is not possible. Additionally, in subject-specific classes, teachers are probably not aware of student reading levels.  The best many teachers can do is to prepare an appropriate range of text selections and make them available in Box or DropBox for students to access.

On the other hand, there are iPad tools to help students accurately read "just wrong" text.  They also support understanding of texts that are a good fit.
  • Kindle books have an on-board dictionary - place the cursor before a word and initiate an instant "lookup."  iBooks also has a dictionary - press on a word and define is an option.  Both tools also enable web search, highlighting, annotations attached to text, searching by word (character or place names, for example), and bookmarking.  iBooks is a little friendlier for kids.
  • Readability is an app (as well as a web-based widget) that "cleans up" web text (it works best with article text - does not work with all text) so that distractions are removed. Search for articles in Readability's own browser (which makes the process much simplier) or access the tool through Safari (as is done on a non-mobile platform).  Articles can be saved for viewing offline and can be quickly shared (via email, most likely, but HS students can also instantly Tweet articles), which increases motivation to read accurately. You might want the ad-free version for a small charge.  Pressing on a word in Readability gives the reader the option to define a word (also true in the Safari browser when running the Readability bookmark widget). Text can be formatted in various ways as well.  Readability is a bit difficult to install and configure, and it requires an account, so you will want to do the setup yourself.  
  • Safari Reader will appear as a choice on a web page that is recognized as journal-type text. Clicking on it has the same effect as Readability.  This is great for newspapers, online magazines, etc.  but it does not work on blog text. 
  • GoodReader is an annotation reader for .pdf files.  Using email, Dropbox or other apps, load .pdf  files onto the student's iPad.  The ability to annotate (lines, text, colors) while reading denser text will help with accurate reading.  You can also direct reading by including focus and pre-reading questions at the top of the text, by chunking text, and adding vocabulary definitions, etc.  This is especially useful for informational text.   
  • Notability is another good .pdf reader that annotates.  It has the advantage of combining with Joliprint so that .pdf files created from Safari accessed web pages can be opened immediately on the iPad (Joliprint creates .pdf files from web pages).
  • Speak Selection in the iPad Accessibility Settings can be turned on to enable a student reader to hear a word or a text selection spoken by a machine voice (Siri - set the voice to be quite slow!).  This is a pop-up option, along with define and copy (one word - selection).  VoiceOver can also be turned on, which means that ALL text will be spoken. This is useful if you are working with a student in an iBook or a web-reading assignment, but also very frustrating.  Not really recommended.
  • i-Prompt Pro is a free app designed for presentations and speech-making. It scrolls text (pasted into the app) for oral reading, making it a terrific tool for small group, all-class, or individual fluency development, or simply for sharing a fabulous text selection.  Modeling made easy.
  • Web Reader HD ($4.99) will speak just about any text, including web pages opened in its own browser and files opened from Dropbox.  This latter can be huge for differentiated reading.
  • Speak It! - Text to Speech ($1.99) will speak text that is entered (copy-pasted any text), highlighting words as they are read. The app is used often as an assistive device, but it is also good for fluency, accuracy, and understanding of text read. Another advantage is a choice of voices.
  • Voice Memos for iPad - Since this app multi-tasks, a student can record himself/herself reading, but also record comments about reading while reading. Share via email, or simply pass the iPad around a reading group.
  • Dragon Dictation can be used for fluency improvement as well, although this is not its primary purpose. 
  • Evernote is also a simple tool for capturing oral reading.  See #50 in this slide show for How-to.  
  • Or, if you are really lucky and have the new iPad, activate the Dictation Key. Students can read and see syllables, words, and sentences recreated on the notepad.  How-to.
  • Evernote Peak is a great way to check reading accuracy. It is basically a Q & A app - ask a question and "peak" at the answer by lifting a virtual or real iPad cover.  Students can create questions in an Evernote notebook to share, teachers can do the same.  All free.  
  • Almost any text-based webpage (not site) can be saved as an ePub document and opened in Notability, iBooks, or other .epub reader by using dotEPUB, which is a widget installed as a Safari bookmark.  Follow the link to get the directions (warning - if the document you create is a selection from The Man Who Was Thursday, you have done the right thing).  As noted above, some readers will let students annotate, others will help students to decode or speak the text for them. 
3. Every child reads something he or she understands.  The point here is that what a student reads, especially during reading intervention, must be within a context that he understands - not out-of-context text - and the text must be rich enough so that there is something to understand.  One way in which the iPad can support understanding is by providing rich media support for the context of the reading. Below are just a few ways in which this can be quickly done using the multi-tasking capabilities of the iPad (double-tap on the Home button and scroll through open apps).  All of the tools above also support reading for understanding, thoughtful reading, as do the apps in #4 and #5 below.  Thus the iPad itself provides a stimulus for reading to understand.
  • Google app - use the Voice Search capability for pre-reading and during-reading engagement - look for the icon at the bottom of the launch window
  • Google Earth app - look up places, settings, etc.
  • Qwiki - multi-media, narrated videos on many topics, including some best-selling student novels
  • (see text-to-speech apps above)
  • Teachers can record their own reading of texts using any one of a wide range of tools.  Students can record their thoughts and understandings in short audio files. Here are a few very good tools:
    • AudioBoo
    • VoiceThread (central to which is a comment feature, written, oral, uploaded sound file)
    • DropVox (record directly to a DropBox folder in a designated account - from here, files can be "back-shared")
    • TinyVox - quickly record with the option to redo - uploads (and archives on iPad) to a unique URL that can be shared.  Use this to generate questions and well as understandings.  
    • Talking Tom and Ben News - For elementary students, but also higher (with clever ideas), this app speaks back what students enter, with dualing voices.  I can see lots of opportunities for digital hot seats, interviews, etc.
Book Creator
4. Every child writes about something personally meaningful.  How can a teacher quickly understand if a student is reading "right fit" text?  Ask the student what his response is, ask that it be spoken, written, drawn - and make time for reading responses to be shared. The rationale for this is in the article.  There is no substitute for an alert teacher who is an active listener and observer - but the iPad can help.
  • Just writing:  Pages is the tool of choice, even though it is not free.  Students keeping lengthy documents over the course of a year can export them as ePub files, readable in iBooks.  For that alone Pages is worth it.
  • Audio-journaling:  see the tools listed above for voice recording.
  • Drawing:  Some students will "write" best by drawing in place of - or in addition to - writing text.  This drawing is often accompanied in elementary school with a voice narration. Again, the iPad has numerous tools for this.  These tools are often called screencasting apps when used by adults.
    • ShowMe - the most basic app for drawing and adding a voice record
    • ReplayNote4Kid and ScreenChomp are a bit more complex, but easily used in elementary school
    • Educreations is a bit more complex, for middle and high school.
    • Keynote is terrific for longer responses, as to an entire novel or unit of study. 
    • BookCreator is an alternative to Pages for in-depth ePub documents or for gathering writing done over time.  With the inclusion of audio, it can be a digital portfolio of reading growth.
  • Journaling: In the old days, ELA teachers called this journaling or free-writing post-reading.  Tools for this abound on the iPad.  A few: 
    • MyMemoir - this app appears on very few lists, but I find it to be the most convenient for journaling
    • Notes - minimally featured note-taking tool is just plain easy to use
    • Noteability - for upper-middle and HS student readers, this richly featured app is wonderful
    • Noteshelf - an alternative to Noteability ($5.99) recommended for situations in which many students use the same iPad because individual note journals can easily be created (video)
    • Evernote - attached to an online account, this has a journal-type interface - audio, photos, can be tagged by author, text, etc.  
    • Dragon Dictation is a great tool for those students who can not, or will not, keyboard 
    • Or, if you are really lucky and have the new iPad, activate the Dictation Key. Students can read and see syllables, words, and sentences recreated on the notepad.  How-to. 
  • Brainstorming or Mind-mapping:  Sentences are important, but understanding and interest are often captured in abbreviated form as well.   
    • Mindo is my app of choice, but may overwhelm younger students
    • Popple Lite is a much simpler app that has the kid advantage of letting images be easily inserted into maps
  • Organizers can be contrived, but for many struggling thinkers they provide a concrete structure.  Tools4Students is an app for that.  It contains a fairly large selection of organizers to scaffold responses to reading.
  • Annotating:  Textual notes are essential as a during-reading response.  For print text, post-its and pencils do the trick.  The problem is that the notes get lost, are difficult to organize, and are generally difficult to use in open discussion.  The iPad makes it possible for students to easily annotate digital text in a variety of ways (depending on the tool).  A few good tools:
    • Skitch - draw, add text boxes to text images - For example, take a picture of a page of text, a document, a magazine article after reading - annotate!  Shares directly to Evernote
    • GoodReader - many tools for annotating .pdf files
    • iBook - annotate ePub texts
    • Webnotes - the perfect tool to use for recording understanding and responses while reading web text.  Does not work with Readability or Safari Reader text, however, as it uses its own browser.  Text can be copy-pasted into the side-by-side Notes pane, encouraging students to take steps toward analysis.
  • Creative "writing" - Some teachers feel that responses to reading must directly address, in writing, what has been read, kind of like CCSS thinking. I don't believe that is always the best way to respond to reading.  So I offer some other ideas:
    • Visual Poet combines text and images into visual poetry, which can be uploaded to a Tumblr (an online blogging platform that I don't really recommend for school over the others mentioned above) account or sent in an e-mail (say, to an Evernote folder).  I am certain that other interconnectivity is in the works.  There are some negative reviews of this app, but it is a herald of future uses of the iPad, so try it.
    • Camera, the built-in iPad app, is great.  Some editing can be done in Photo beginning with IOS 5, but Camera Plus contains a better set of editing tools, including the b&w effect that is great for student response shots.  Pair this with Skitch (easier - see above) or Photogene (for the serious photo-commentator) to turn pictures into messages.  
    • ComicLife  or Comics Creator makes a comic message, which is sometimes what students want to convey - use photos, saved images, or screenshots and "voice bubbles"
    • iStopMotion - use the camera, voice-over, and onboard tools to make video "stories" - has the great feature of combining with a free camera app on iPhone (or 2nd iPad) to instantly upload 2-party photos into the editing timeline.  
    • PicStitch creates photo collages with or without some message text

Blog Docs
 5. Every child talks with peers about reading and writing.  I am sure that Allington is thinking about f2f conversations, but digital conversations are now as possible, and often as frequent, as f2f. They have the advantages of being asynchronous and accessible (to the talker and the listener/commenter) 24/7.  Moreover, in using the iPad for these conversations, students are developing key 21st Century skills.
  • Voice recording
    • Voice Memos for iPad - since this app multi-tasks, a student can record himself/herself reading, but also record comments about reading while reading - share via email, or simply pass the iPad around a reading group
    • Audio Memos (paid version is more versatile) is a similar app, but it allows for stop-start recording
    • SoundCloud - record up to 120 minutes of audio (no editing) - share with a unique URL - best with 1 acct. / iPad (not great for shared iPads)
  • Blogging - Teachers should have RSS feeds to these spaces, but so should other students.  At the elementary and middle level (students below 12), teachers should create accounts and complete the iPad setup, which makes posting a snap.  Blogging can be done individually or by a group (thematic, subject, title).  Remember that the comment feature on a blog is an  essential part of the conversation.
    •  Students with existing Google accounts (often provided by the school for blogging and mail) can use the Google Blogger application to blog their thoughts. 
    • Posterous is an easy way for students to upload short posts to an existing blog - most platforms work, and many blogs can be accessed (probably too hard for elementary school) [alert: Posterous has been bought out by Twitter - this will eventual lead to change, so you might go with a different app if you are just starting]
    • Blogsy is another simplified blogging tool.  Like Posterous, pictures and videos can be added.
    • Blog Docs - A sophisticated blogging platform from Google best for adept iPad users.  It has the enormous advantage of sophisicated features, including handwriting/annotation, tables, lists, highlighting...   Best used with an existing Wordpress or Blogger account (can be a Google Blogger account).
  • Collaborative Spaces for virtual conversations
    • VoiceThread
    • DropVox - record directly into a student blog space
    • Google Docs, also accessed through the Google app, is a sharing space perfect for upper middle and high school students.  It works best if accounts are created by the school, including email, so that the full range of Google Applications can be accessed and quickly shared by all students and faculty (one contact list).
    • Use zapd to create a theme, lit circle, or subject specific, or other web site that many students can access. (This is an iPhone app that works in iPad as well.)
Open Culture
6. Every child listens to a fluent adult read aloud.  Allington prefers a f2f read-aloud, and this is often possible. On the other hand, it becomes less and less desirable both time-wise and culture-wise as students scaffold up grade-wise.  I know many teachers disagree with me, but I believe that the middle school read-aloud experience after grade 6 is overrated as an element of reading instruction (also true for HS).  The iPad can provide students with other ways to listen to fluent reading.
  • Any one of the audio recording apps above can be used by teachers to pre-record fluent readings of short or longer texts.  These can, of course, be used over and over again, and shared via web-page, blog post, DropBox or Box.
  • AudioBooks provides access to a huge library of texts that can be listened to with or without texts.
  • Audible.com sells quality audio recordings that can be downloaded to a Kindle acct. or directly to the iPad as audio files.  
  • OverDrive Media Console will connect students with library cards to public or school libraries with a e-Book loan service.  This includes audio books.
  • And why just reading?  The TED talks are fluent adult voices, as are the many interviews available through Open Culture.  
  • Open Culture also links to hundreds of high quality audio books.
All-in-all, I think this is a pretty powerful argument for 1:1 iPad programs.

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Colum McCann on Fiction, Writing, and Stories

If you have not found YouTube's new IntelligentChannel (INT.), visit it now.

My focus is the 1st program, an interview with Colum McCann entitled "The Paul Holdengraber Show with Colum McCann: On the Radical Act of Storytelling."

The video:



Great quotes to spur discussion:

 About the value of story: "Stories are the ultimate democracy."

About the writer's craft: "The little anonymous corner is sometimes the best place for a story to come from."  (this quote would be nice paired with Seth Worley's short video Plot Device)

About the importance of the reader: "There is no creative writing without a creative reader.  The reader has to go in and her or she makes the book, and can make as little of it as they want or as much of it as they want."

About the relationship of the writer and the reader: "I want to paint a photograph for my reader and then her or  him to step into that photograph and move it along for themselves, and that's what you do with language...and then they go on their own journey; it's not mine anymore.  And readers can be infinitely wiser than the writer is."

About writing: "I always fail; we always fall short of the expectations that we want for the work to be. And that for me is a good thing."

About turning events into fiction (paraphrased):  The stories of today need to be told over, and over, and over again so that no one storyteller owns the truth.  There should be no one "official story" of history - writers have a duty to go into history and find the little anonymous corners that will tell the story.

And did you know that Frederick Douglass spent a year in starving Ireland on the speaker circuit while, at 27, he was still a slave? "Trying to make sense of what it means to be other, and yet look after your own people at the same time." 

McCann specifically addresses Let The Great World Spin and its allegorical connections to 9/11, the Iraq War, and other current events.

Subscribe to this new Channel and, if you teach McCann or read him, listen to this interview.  


Saturday, January 7, 2012

The Literacy of Critical Evaluation: Why Rating is Not Good Enough

Essential Question: How Do We Teach Critical Evaluation in ELA?


source
Realization phase: I realized today that the average book rating on Amazon is over 4 stars.  I am fairly sure that the average app rating in iTunes is also over 4 stars. Zappo boots have an average overall rating of over 4 stars as well.  How can these ratings possibly be useful?  Yet they are embedded in today's concept of "smart shopping." 

The concept of an overall rating is dangerous.  Consumers - of products or information - who rely upon the "star reports" are not thinking critically or evaluatively, as they believe they are doing.  They are thinking quantitatively and shallowly.  Unfortunately, the ubiquitous nature of crowd-sourced rating systems today means that our students are participating in, and taking advice from, a thinking habit that is dumbing down their own ability to think and evaluate critically.

Insight phase: Critical thinking habits can be and need to be addressed in the classroom, or we run the risk of raising a group of satisfied sloppy thinkers.  [And those thinkers will, in some states, be rating teachers. In all states, they will be voting.]

Parenting groups are actively promoting the teaching of critical thinking.  For example, the issue is confronted directly in recent articles:
Aside from psychology professors, parents are the most prevalent online writers about this topic. They want their children to be "brainy" and successful.  They are not seeing that schools will do the job.

And they are right to be concerned.  Although critical thinking is identified as a key 21st century learning target,  and it is probably going to be embedded in new standards-based assessments, it is clearly difficult to pin-point how to develop it, much less to get good advice from experienced educators.  There is even sigificant disagreement about whether or not critical thinking can and should be addressed before the middle level years (clearly, the parent-educators have no such qualms - and I agree with that).  So what is the target for developing critical evaluation as a habit of mind?
source
Learning phase: My learning journey today in this area leads me to identify these elements of critical thinking:
  • Writing - Persuasive/Arugmentative especially
  • Questioning - questions asked before intereacting with text/media; questions asked during and after
  • Debating
  • Connection to authentic experience (life)
  • Creativity
  • Investigation or research
  • Systematic truth-seeking
  • Fair-mindedness (consideration of the opinions and insights of others, consideration for point of view)
In the ELA classroom, these elements need to be applied to literacy tasks, specifically reading text (including visual and media text) and writing about this text.  These are habits of mind, not skills.

As spelled out in Paul and Elder's The International Critical Thinking Reading & Writing Test (.pdf sample pages from The Critical Thinking Community), close reading and substantive writing require skills that enable students to take ownership of the ideas in a text.  These skills are:
  1. Clarify purposes: an author’s purpose(s) (when we read), and our own purpose(s) (when we write).
  2. Formulate clear questions: those that an author is asking (as we read) and those we are pursuing (as we write).
  3. Distinguish accurate and relevant information from inaccurate and irrelevant  information: in texts that we read and in preparation for our own writing.
  4. Reach logical inferences or conclusions: based on what we read, and in preparation for writing.
  5. Identify significant and deep concepts: those of an author and those we want to guide our thinking while we write.
  6. Distinguish justifiable from unjustifiable assumptions: that an author is using, or that we are using in our own thinking as we write.
  7. Trace logical implications: those of an author’s thinking, and those that may follow from our written work.
  8. Identify and think within multiple viewpoints: those that an author presents (or fails to present when relevant) and those relevant to the issues in our written work (and that we need to include).
Critical evaluation (phase) is the end product of the application of these elements.  The materials available at The Critical Thinking Community site (all for sale, some freely available) will provide the district or school with clear guides to improving student critical thinking.  If this is not an option, I recommend that all ELA teachers in the US should study the sample Critical Reading/Writing "text" - with anchor answers - for The Declaration of Independence (it is contained in the .pdf file).  This would be a great professional development or PLC activity.

Also of great use to ELA teachers are the following tools provided on The Critical Thinking Community site:
  • an overview of The Elements of Thought - an expansion of the pie above,
  • 35 Dimensions of Critical Thought,
  • remodeled lessons, which can be accessed through the navigation bar at the 35 Dimensions page (lessons reference the strategies) - I especially liked the remodeled Journal and Argumentative Writing lessons in the Junior High School section.
source
Simplification: All of this might be to complex for some teachers, however.  For these, a focus on Bloom's Taxonomy Revised (.pdf) is in order.  The top two tiers apply directly to critical evaluation:
  • Evaluating: Making judgments based on criteria and standards through checking and critiquing.
  • Creating: Putting elements together to form a coherent or functional whole; reorganizing elements into a new pattern or structure through generating, planning, or producing. 
The above explanation is from Mary Forehand - Bloom's Taxonomy.  Notice that producing is only one element of creating.  ELA teachers should not focus overly on creative projects or products - this emphasis is a flaw in most information about the Creating element.  Yes, it is the most fun part for students - the whole benefit of critical thinking is lost if the evaluative step is not embedded in the creative step.

For example, if the Essential Question for an ELA unit is the one I posed in my last post, Why are zombies compelling?  students might create a zombie movie as a culminating project.  Does this demonstrate critical understanding of the genre or the question?  Nope.  On the other hand, a video interview with the director, cast, and screenwriter of that imagined movie would be able to demonstrate a critical understanding of the question.

The key, therefore, is twofold (no surprises here, but reminders are in order):
  1. The texts must be worthy of critical evaluation - complex, challenging, accessible on multiple levels, question-raising
  2. The student tasks must (post-Analysis) address the Evaluating and Creating tiers of Blooms.  Paul and Elder strongly support the argument that the best of these tasks are also social in nature.  In other words, the culminating topic or assignment must be evaluative in nature. 
Conclusion: Which brings us back to ratings.  Critical shoppers ignore the overall rating and go directly to the reviews, which they read critically (Is there an agenda here? Does the review address the product? Does it provide me with real information? etc.).  Or goal is for students to always do the same.

Practical applications:
  • Taking a page from my Zombies unit, students could critically evaluate one of the texts by Brooks, a children's book, and one of the web texts - does it get better than that?
  • Detailed rubrics can provide students with some language for critical evaluation. Use them often and honestly, and insist that students read the evaluation text! Unfortunately, they are not readily available. 
  • It would be interesting to design a year-long critical evaluation focus with the thematic frame of Ratings Defended.  How would this be done?  Students would have to not only rate texts, responses to text (each other), models, etc. - they would be required to defend and explain each rating.  I can't think of a better use of:
I think this would eventually improve the whole value of social rating.  And I personally would begin as early as pre-K, where "thumbs up" is still a valid rating system. 

Resources to read and intrigue you:
  • Critical Thinking: Why is it so hard to teach?  (Daniel Willingham) (.pdf download)
  • Try this new widget - it is supposed to provide a critical thinking question every day (as well as to model the best forms of questioning):




Sunday, August 29, 2010

Another reason to de-block social networks

I have spent 4 days and considerable time beyond that this summer working with colleagues to draft a workable Reading Workshop program, k-8.  This is not a paradigm shift for me, but it once was.  I began 30+ years ago with a large literature text, the same text I found on the shelves of my new classroom 7 years ago today.  I closed it for good about 20 years ago and have not had the students open it once since (hyperbole, but not by much).  Unlike 50-50 reporting on the reading-value of SSR programs, current research overwhelmingly supports a reading workshop model with authentic reading tasks (fiction, poetry, drama, informational lit) at the "just right" reading level of each individual child.

Which makes teaching ELA more work and data-collection time-consuming.

Which may be large parts of the reason for the Milwaukee Public Schools to adapt k-5 and 6-8 literature/literacy/reading text series (the same by any name).  Here is a blog post about it from the Literacy Coaches group.  Be a good skimmer and read the 1st paragraph and the last.  You will get the gist.

Here is a blog post from a different forum about teaching the series (scroll down a little).  Perhaps Milwaukee should have included teachers in the decision-making.  I stopped here in my research into HM's series, but I could have gone on.

My point is this:  By accessing forum and blog posts, I have accessed authentic ideas and opinions, accessed new ideas, and been forced to evaluate my "1st response" to Milwaukee's decision.  I do this every day, all year by getting email feeds from my fav group (English Companion) and surfing for blog posts and articles in areas that interest me.  Although I like to learn on my own, I embrace the fact that I am not the only one interested in a topic or idea.

Isn't this what we really want our students to do as readers of informational text?  When we block them from reading and participating in social networking environments, we deny them this opportunity for authentic learning.

A last thought:  I wonder if Milwaukee opened its textbook selection committee to students? If I were that superintendent, I would have made it possible for students, teachers and parents to review and blog about the series choices for at least half of a year.  Authentic input = conversation = better decision-making = better education.

Monday, July 19, 2010

A new skin and 100 bags

I have taken ownership of my laptop. Against the "rules."  I now have a forest green keyboard and my trademark "web" around the white apple.  The "web" is the nicer skin, but the keyboard skin came with cleaning pads (alcohol, like you get from a doctor) and a great smoothing tool that pushed all the bubbles out.  Yes, they cost a little, but the expense worth it.  I am no longer a random MacBook user - I am now a Mrs.Mac's MacBook user.  

What does this have to do with Literacy?  Tons. 

It's about ownership.  I and endless others have written about the value of the ownership of reading - choice, circles, choice, discussion, listening to discussion, publication.  What I realize from my readings of blogs, nings and cries for help is this: student ownership of literacy learning is all important to success, but unfortunately it is not the administrative goal du jour.  There is a nice little skin available that promotes online learning, literature/reading circles, alternative demonstrations of learning - and most teachers are told not to wear it.

When the cake is on the table this fall, I suspect that most public school teachers will be asked to work with, or develop, a uniform literacy curriculum - many are already doing so. 

Where does this leave the teacher who believes in the 4 C's (critical thinking and problem solving, collaboration, communication, and creativity and innovation)?  Often, high and dry.

I wear my skins in protest.

But, I am also working on my own to make change happen.  Here is part of my plan:

Frustration Addressed: Absolute benchmarked quantities of reading required outside of school - whether a challenge or a graded activity (400 pages, 20 minutes/day, 25 texts, 4 novels, 40 journal entries, etc.).  I have wrestled with this all summer. There is no doubt in my mind that personal reading is the greatest indicator of - What?  Truthfully - I don't know What, save the data that points to college completion and employment.  I am going with the deep emotional, creative and intellectual gains made from time lost to reading.  It can not - and is not - assessed, but it is the most crucial skill I want my students to hone.  My district expects me go spend hours with graphic organizers, test scores, personal benchmarks, standards, and vocabulary and reading skill-sets and activities - and to pass these hours on to my students.  Ho, Hum.  I expect my students to want to learn because they want to learn.  And to read because they want to read.  60% or more of my kids are there already.  I am frustrated by the other 40%.

Action Plan: I have ordered 100 cotton tote bags (at my own expense - might be able to charge it to supplies) with the logo:  LEGO ERGO SUM (I read therefore I am).  I will put in each bag, over the course of the summer and the year, a pair of texts (novels, plays, prints, story collections, picture books, manuals, guides, histories, photocopies...) and challenge my students to make connections between them and with them (self, author, world...).  In the bags will be questions and challenges that surpass dry worksheets.  The work will be independent,  partnering will be always an option, collaboration with previous readers an option, and it all will be by choice. Most discussion will be online - I will be available for an hour every evening for chat, mail and Skype.   Students will be encouraged to create their own Book Bags for peers and students in Grade 6, to guide this reading, and to leave me totally out of the learning loop. 

Anticipated Outcome: I expect to see LEGO ERGO SUM all over the school. 

Other Comments: If I could afford it, I would give every reader a skin announcing LEGO ERGO SUM.  Or perhaps LEGO ERGO COGITO.  Wouldn't that be a message to the administration!