Showing posts with label critical thinking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label critical thinking. Show all posts

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Myth #7: Digital Learning Develops Problem-Solving

8 Myths About Digital Learning

OK - I have to compromise on this one. I do believe that using digital tools develops the problem-solving skills necessary to use "new" digital tools.  In fact, I suspect that the thinking that leads children to succeed in any problem-solving digital game becomes a habit of mind that helps in solving similar non-digital, real-life problems.  Students who can, for example, advance steadily in Cut the Rope are more likely to be able make suggestions to get a team over a wall challenge or are more likely to contribute key language to a class constitution.

Here are some problem-solving basics (this is my own list):

  • I have to understand the problem and what makes it hard
  • I have to think about what I already "know" about the problem topic
  • I have to take a deep breath and think critically about what I read, see, think, feel, hear, and already "know" - throw out the unimportant, wrong, false, exaggerated, emotional, and biased
  • If I don't see a solution, I have to take a risk and try something different
  • If I do nothing, there will be no solution
  • I have to accept and learn from my mistakes, missteps, and failures
  • I have to give this time
  • If I find a solution right away, this doesn't mean I have the best solution
  • Some problems are too hard for just me
  • Being in a team has advantages, so listen to team members
  • Finding, keeping, and evaluating evidence and experience as I work for a solution is important
  • I have to test my solution (unless it obviously works)
  • Solving a hard problem gets me ready for an even harder problem and makes me better at similar problems
Problem-solving requires Critical Thinking. In education, Critical Thinking is today thought of as, well, critical.  As expressed in this post from Educational Technology and Mobile Learning, it has these elements:

Other researchers use different terminology for critical thinking skills:
It's In the Genes
Whichever language you choose, notice that individual judgment and opinion are embedded in these research models of Critical Thinking (on this point I quibble with critical thinking as applied by the Common Core to reading.  Personal response and previous knowledge matter. Enough said).  Note also that research supports that critical thinking skills can be taught, but also that once learned, they are not applied with automaticity by any individual.  Their optimum application in the classroom should, therefore, be monitored, and must be required.

The above research article (It's In the Genes) also states that problem-solving style preferences are innate (adaptive/narrow solution focused or innovative/wide solution focused).  This suggests to me that the design of an educational problem is, for many students, directly related to its outcomes - for an individual student and for a problem-solving team.  This requires a teacher or teaching team.

[Aside: the relationship between Problem-solving and Critical Thinking is a complex one, characterized by overlap and interdependence.  I have found this article to be very helpful in understanding the components of both as they related to education.]

So what?  It is clear to me that the skills of critical thinking can be assisted by digital tools, and to this degree digital learning does develop them.  Multiple cases have been made for the use of technology to enhance and develop each of the elements of critical thinking identified above.  Tools such as blogging and backchanneling can even develop the student's ability to self-examine and self-correct.

On the other hand, problem-solving is not developed, but supported, by technology. Ready access to information, including that previously explored and that converted to knowledge, and the communication of solutions and their analysis, are more easily done with facile use of technology than without.  But it only through solving problems that we get better at solving problems.  Ready access to multiple challenging problems may be better for students than extended access to one large, hard technology-rich problem.

So, when we speak of learning, we do better to speak of Critical Thinking.  When we speak of gathering and demonstrating learning - of the processes of learning (writing, reading, researching) - we do better to speak of solving problems.

I have touched on this previously:

Monday, January 7, 2013

Myth #6: Digital Learning is Creative

made on iPad
8 Myths About Digital Learning

The myth is not that digital tools can be used creatively or to create. The myth is that digital creativity is essential in the k12 classroom.

As long as Creativity is one of the 3 C's or 4 C's of 21st century learning, the myth will persist.  When it became a C-word, creativity was raised to mythic level in the k12 world.  It sits there now as a goal of digital learning.  But what does that involve?

Creative thought and innovation do not require a digital environment, re. Bruce Mau's Manifesto #29: "Think with your mind...Creativity is not device-dependent".  My thinking leads me to believe that creativity and innovation require, in order:
  1. the ability to access the whole of one's experiences and learning (obviously the more of both the better)
  2. the inclination to think about the whole of one's experiences and learning
  3. intuition - the ability to recognize the right combination of these experiences and learning to apply to the project or problem at hand
  4. introspection - time for ideas to percolate, collect, and coalesce - time for intuition to happen
Ron Berger of Expeditionary Schools would argue that persistence is also a necessary part of creativity. I agree, having taken it off of my list because persistence transcends the digital world. Read Ron's excellent post about Deeper Learning.

I would argue that, in most k12 classrooms, digital learning is - should be - more about developing than creating, and in this I suspect that Ron and I agree. Each item on the above list is a skill, or mind-set, than can be developed and enhanced by digital tools.  Without the skills, innovation and creativity will not happen in the student's post-HS world.  We need to alter the digital focus - let students go about the business of developing and take the focus off of creative product.

The digital environment certainly applies to #1 - the ability to access the whole of one's experiences and learning. It enables a curious or diligent student to expand experiences and learning through the internet. The digital environment is not the only way, perhaps not even the best way, as the movement toward PBL and experience-based learning suggests. Realistically, however, it is trending.

Additionally, digital tools used to catalog, collect and share learning or information objects can certainly enhance a student's access to what has been digitally explored. Pinterest, Wallwisher, Scoop.it, Wikispaces and similar sites and apps are widely used for this purpose. What makes these especially cool tools is the crowdsourcing of ideas and experiences that they allow. Students are no longer limited to their own catalog.  

The best case scenario is that students will move from collecting/accessing to #2 - thinking about the ideas.   Listen also to NPR's mashup of three different TED talks that relate to the relationship of groups to ideas, Where Ideas Come From.  Matt Ridley and Steven Johnson (they have their own TED talks) talk to the need for access to ideas from a diversity of others.

Often enough, however, the apps used to provide this access, and the assignments made, encourage a superficial sense of accomplishment, not unlike an adult might feel after pinning 20 web images of crystal ice buckets.  Using the tools effectively in education, on the other hand, makes them about developing ideas, whether the topic be vocabulary, characterization, or close literary analysis.  

[There is hope. Check out this list of 27 Ways to publish student thinking [my emphasis]. Making the process more important than a (creative) product is the right road for k12 learning.]

The digital environment applies also to #3 - intuition, the ability to recognize the right combination of these experiences and learning for the project or problem at hand. Viewing "creation" tools as a means of exploring combinations of experiences and understandings/learning, rather than as platforms for final expression, is important.

Students need to learn the depth and value and uses of multiple tools so that they will be able to best employ tools of the future. Tools for mashing up collected information and media in visual, audio and multimedia environments are readily available for any 1:1 platform (see, for example, this review of Screencasting Apps for the iPad, and other excellent apps, such as Prizi, Haiku Deck, Wixie, DoodleCast (Pro and for Kids), Animoto, iMovie and Drop'n'Roll/V.I.K.T.O.R).  

made in ShowMe
Teachers, however, often mistake engaging presentations full of  original artwork and music for creative and innovative thinking.  Myth #6 encourages this. The fact is that many students excel at media bells and whistles. Since most digital projects assigned are about content, not about the growth of learning, it is easy for student to do use the "fun" work of media-making rather than the hard work of thinking.

The myth-breaking fact is that most student content-products lack depth of thought, instead relaying surface knowledge that could as easily be conveyed on posterboard or a short stack of notecards.  This is also true of the polished adult products which serve as models for students. Compare, for example, this Animated History of Malaria to your student products.  Aside from the slickness of the animation, it does little more to demonstrate creative understanding of the topic than would a picture book.

A simple student audio file attached to a project, digital notes, or an oral presentation is always a better measure of thought and learning than is the project itself.

Or, better yet, have students truly create products from Scratch, as discussed in this guest blog post by Rob Ackerman.  This applies to HyperStudio and other Logo media products as well, staples of many defunct computer labs.

Which brings us to the importance of #4 - introspection, or time for ideas to percolate, collect, and coalesce.

If you have not already done so, listen to Susan Cain's TED Talk The Power of Introverts.  Cain, the author of best seller and Best Nonfiction title Quiet, is passionate about the need of individuals  - and she directly addresses both education the workplace - for isolated quiet time. In this time, ideas happen. In this time, creativity brews. She attacks the myth that "the new creativity comes from a .... gregarious place."  An extrapolation of her talk is the suggestion that the digital learning environment, although it plays a role in the development of creative ideas, is not ideal for nurturing them.

Many of my students would argue that the digital world serves as "background" for thinking, much as music helps many to read.  When we accept this as true, we also accept the vacuity of much of the digital student experience.  Learning how to disconnect, then, is a skill for our students to develop.

How to turn your classroom into an idea factory, from Mindshift, provides eight solid suggestions - not one of which includes the word "digital."  The pedagogy of reaching out to a larger-than-classroom world is, however, embedded in "the idea factory" concept. Of course, this pedagogy does not require digital devices beyond the phone. (In fact, it can be argued that a face-to-face conversation with a real person is more powerful than a tweet stream in terms of input from an authentic contributor to a thought stream.)

Creative thought just might come most often, most successfully, post-digitally.  Or altogether non-digitally.

[Note: An additional dimension of creative possibility is found in digital tools that are ONLY for creative expression. The art-focused apps found in 10 Essential Apps for the Digital Artist and Creating on the iPads, and serious apps for music (see Creating music with iPads, which could but does not mention Garageband or other basic apps), are tools with which students can, in fact, create original artworks. Students have always been able to write creatively, but digital tools (such as the screencast and movie-making tools mentioned above) open up a new dimension of digital storytelling. However, not many ELA or history students will use these same tools creatively to demonstrate content learning. Using them productively requires a level of competency and (dare I say it) talent that is outside of the mainstream in the ELA classroom, and therefore not considered in this post.]

Thursday, February 2, 2012

The Literacy of Failure: Failing and Failing Forward

Source: CC Search
Failure is the new buzz word for the classroom.  Just today I read that good classroom apps for the  iPad embrace failure: "this culture of learning from adversity" (Jenny Magiera).  Interestingly, while professing to discuss failure, Magiera is really talking about adversity and success through personalization and differentiation.

Failure and adversity are not the same thing.  Adversity means difficulties or misfortune.  The word carries the connotation that a successful struggle is waged against these difficulties or misfortunes. Adversity is a temporary down.  Ironically, in YA literature, a protagonist's adversity is often caused by adult failures: divorce, neglect, abuse, abandonment, confusion, ineptitude...

Failure, on the other hand, means lack of success.  Implied in failure as descriptor is action -  something is tried that does not work. Failure is a real down.  Educators are easy on adversity, if slow to embrace it, but they shy away from failure. 

This is what the career-focused message of talking heads is all about.  It's time to get tougher in the classroom, so that failure is a very real, even probable, option.  Learning how to face it, get up and begin again, or change direction and focus so that success is a different option, are what is missing from today's classrooms.  But not missing from life.


The above two Rules from Dumbing Down Our Kids by Charles Sykes say it well.  Unfortunately,  not even iPad apps are created in the spirit of failure - sorry, teachers who think new apps are a panacea for the "have it too easy" generations.  As Magiera has learned, they are useful for working through how a failure happened, but so is f2f conversation.

How then, do students learn how to fail forward - learn how to learn from failure?

The ELA teacher can help. Experienced teachers know that failure is embedded in the writing process, and that talking though writing failures is essential to improvement.

Students should not only write, but also read, about failure.  Models for failure in YA novels are few and far between, but they can be found.  Adversity, on the other hand, is all over the place - it is perhaps the soul of fiction, memoir and creative non-fiction.  If reading about adversity were enough, we would not be pounded over the head with the message that "failure is the [missing] key to success."  To learn about failure, students need to (1) experience it and (2) read engaging texts about it. 

What are the key identifiers of a good literary failure?  After reading through both business and educational discussions of the topic, I identify these traits that we should look for in failure-based texts:
  • A character exhibits a growth in character through the failure - no growth, no rising above failure (some characters wallow in it) and no avoiding it later on
  • A character who bounces back from failure displays "zest, grit, self-control, social intelligence, gratitude, optimism and curiosity" while doing so (source: NYTimes) - to which I would add adaptability.  My criticism of this list of traits is that is not enough to differentiate failure from overcoming adversity. 
  • Failure is a result of intentional (not accidental) risk-taking
  • Failure is scary - characters fear the consequences of failure
  • Failure results when the challenge is hard or when it requires a significant change in behavior or expectation
  • Failure is a result of a character's own shortcomings
  • There is no shelter from a good failure - no safety net - or it won't happen (e.g.  the character is on his/her own)
  • Bouncing back from failure requires seeking and listening to good feedback, and then doing something different. There is quite a science growing around the idea of failing forward, which Bob Sutton in the Harvard Business Review (blog) describes as "The basic idea is, as soon as feasible after some action occurs, a facilitator and/or teacher should have a conversation with the key participants about what went right, what went wrong, and what could be done better next time."
  • Often, bouncing back is not possible - a character must bounce sideways
  • Examining what failed in a successful experience leads to learning
  • Failure is painful
  • For a character, failure can be final - which is to say, it may lead to death (this is also true of a business or a business product) or to an entire change in life's direction (not necessarily a bad thing)
Compare this list to the top 20 lists of YA literature. Few contemporary protagonists, be they normal or extraordinary young people, fail. Those who do fail, and survive failure, do not generally pause to reflect, gather feedback, and metacognate on what went well.  I suggest that most novels read in ELA classrooms are anti-failure models.  Like a classroom or school in which "everyone succeeds" - in which all efforts are roundly praised - contemporary protagonists, even those in darkly dystopian or realistic tales, do not suffer as a result of their own shortcomings.

No wonder we find that teens avoid situations that challenge their shortcomings, that C is the new F, that teachers are not challenging students with problems that can be failed.  Such as novels that are at the top of the Lexile range or essays that ask students to apply difficult ideas to a text.

Below I am providing some Resources for reading failure-based text.  It is interesting to me that most of these resources are at the HS level.  This suggests to me that the adult world of authors also does not believe that children can deal with the idea of failure.  Hmm.

What we need to do is to embed conversation about failure in our classrooms, to open the pipe, so to speak.  All of the resources below can spearhead that discussion.  This conversation is also, of course, an exercise in critical thinking.

Chidren's Books - It is interesting that there are endless lists of children's books about dealing with divorce, disease, disability, death, moving, potty training, and dentistry.  But very few about failure. 
  • Ish (Reynolds) - about not being perfect
  • The Girl Who Never Made Mistakes (Pett and Rubenstein) - an elementary school girl who (learning to fail)
  • The Berenstain Bears - Poppa is often guilty of failure, as are Brother and Sister - a good place to start might be The Berenstain Bears Picnic
  • Peanuts - Charlie Brown
Fiction, Drama - None of these is appropriate for elementary school.  Isn't it curious how few pieces I have identified?  Suggestions welcome.
  • Only You Can Save Mankind (Pratchett) - video game turns out to be real and failure to not win has a consequence (600L)
  • One-Eyed Cat (Fox) - boy shoots cat (1000L)
  • The Stone-Faced Boy (Fox) - failure to deal, but also failure to communicate
  • Wintergirls (Anderson) - eating disorders - one friend fails, the other succeeds (730L)
  • Jellicoe Road - (Marchetta) - consequences of a failure through two generations - fear of failure (820L)
  • Rash (Hautman) - failing forward in a future world (730L)
  • Ender's Game (Scott Card) - in which failure must be redirected (780L)
  • Romeo and Juliette - the failures of support systems  (can be read as early as 7th with some editing)
  • Monster (Myers) - is the failure the boy or the system?
  • Scorpions (Myers) - boy's experiment with gang life (610L)
  • Fahrenheit 451 (Bradbury) - future citizen faces his failure to resist (890L)
  • Othello - failure of trust
  • The Death of a Salesman - the failures of a salesman and father
  • The Mayor of Casterbridge (Hardy) - persistent gloom of failure as only Hardy can do it (1090L)
  • Catcher in the Rye - read as a failure story, is this going to be a failing forward or just the blame game?  (790L)
  • The Spy Who Came In From the Cold (le Carre) - great spy stuff anti-hero - also a new movie 
  • The Secret Agent (Conrad) - an earlier classic spy failure (1030L)
  • Seize the Day (Bellow) - down and out adult
  • Billy Liar (Waterhouse) - Yorkshire youth - 1959 - also a good film
  • Jasper Jones (Silvey) - Australian youth - Vietnam War Era - Prinz Prize and one of my current favorites for YA
Non-fiction - you might find the contrast of the articles and the first text to be ironic.  The irony becomes less when we realize that characters who are alone - who have no one with whom to talk - fail with more finality. 
Film and Media
  • Race to Nowhere - high-powered adolescent girl suicide
  • Fail-Safe (1964) - a classical look at military failure
  • Waiting for Superman - the failure of the educational system
  • Billy Liar (1963)
  • It's a Wonderful Life
  • The Apprentice: The Complete First Season - DVD - no one pounces on failure better than Donald Trump 
  • Iron Chef - TV and DVD of series
  • Survivor - play any episode and focus on the last few minutes: how is failure dealt with?  Is this a growing experience
  • The Amazing Race - play any episode and focus on how teams make adjustments
  • video games or game apps - any shoot 'em game, it seems - "Given that every game eventually ends in failure, there's a surprising amount of variety here" (review of Ziggurat app)

Wednesday, January 18, 2012

Short Free Video: Wouldn't it be a Better Assessment if We Used Video?

Golem
What if instead of responding to an out-of-context quotation, students were asked to use as a Critical Lens a short movie or video?  For example, watch The Monk and the Fish.  Then ask: What is that video all about?  The student's own answer to that question would become the Critical Lens for the essay.

Short videos and films, like short stories and poems, condense the message.  Higher order thinking is required to determine and concisely state the theme or message. There may be several choices, all correct.  Relating this to literary text(s) and to life would be much more interesting to the student => engagement in the assessment => perhaps more accurate results.

Here is a short list of short films that would work for this purpose.  Sorry - you need to look at them to decide their connections to your texts.  Preview them in the classroom or testing room so you can determine if you can access them on your network.

In the future?  Open access films will be part of ELA standardized testing.  You heard it 1st here.  But since the future is not yet here, these films, and others like them, add a new dimension to literature discussions.  Find more by search YouTube and other sources (YouTube is not the only source) for award-winning animation shorts. One excellent source is the Canadian Film Board (CFB), which contains animations of many folktales.
Comment: This is a wonderful use of the individualization that iPads and tablets and smartphones should bring to education.  Not only learning, but also measurement of learning can be put into student hands.

I am indebted to Open Culture and to Design Your Way for providing films that gave me this idea.  Please suggest other movie shorts through Comment or email.

Saturday, January 7, 2012

The Literacy of Critical Evaluation: Why Rating is Not Good Enough

Essential Question: How Do We Teach Critical Evaluation in ELA?


source
Realization phase: I realized today that the average book rating on Amazon is over 4 stars.  I am fairly sure that the average app rating in iTunes is also over 4 stars. Zappo boots have an average overall rating of over 4 stars as well.  How can these ratings possibly be useful?  Yet they are embedded in today's concept of "smart shopping." 

The concept of an overall rating is dangerous.  Consumers - of products or information - who rely upon the "star reports" are not thinking critically or evaluatively, as they believe they are doing.  They are thinking quantitatively and shallowly.  Unfortunately, the ubiquitous nature of crowd-sourced rating systems today means that our students are participating in, and taking advice from, a thinking habit that is dumbing down their own ability to think and evaluate critically.

Insight phase: Critical thinking habits can be and need to be addressed in the classroom, or we run the risk of raising a group of satisfied sloppy thinkers.  [And those thinkers will, in some states, be rating teachers. In all states, they will be voting.]

Parenting groups are actively promoting the teaching of critical thinking.  For example, the issue is confronted directly in recent articles:
Aside from psychology professors, parents are the most prevalent online writers about this topic. They want their children to be "brainy" and successful.  They are not seeing that schools will do the job.

And they are right to be concerned.  Although critical thinking is identified as a key 21st century learning target,  and it is probably going to be embedded in new standards-based assessments, it is clearly difficult to pin-point how to develop it, much less to get good advice from experienced educators.  There is even sigificant disagreement about whether or not critical thinking can and should be addressed before the middle level years (clearly, the parent-educators have no such qualms - and I agree with that).  So what is the target for developing critical evaluation as a habit of mind?
source
Learning phase: My learning journey today in this area leads me to identify these elements of critical thinking:
  • Writing - Persuasive/Arugmentative especially
  • Questioning - questions asked before intereacting with text/media; questions asked during and after
  • Debating
  • Connection to authentic experience (life)
  • Creativity
  • Investigation or research
  • Systematic truth-seeking
  • Fair-mindedness (consideration of the opinions and insights of others, consideration for point of view)
In the ELA classroom, these elements need to be applied to literacy tasks, specifically reading text (including visual and media text) and writing about this text.  These are habits of mind, not skills.

As spelled out in Paul and Elder's The International Critical Thinking Reading & Writing Test (.pdf sample pages from The Critical Thinking Community), close reading and substantive writing require skills that enable students to take ownership of the ideas in a text.  These skills are:
  1. Clarify purposes: an author’s purpose(s) (when we read), and our own purpose(s) (when we write).
  2. Formulate clear questions: those that an author is asking (as we read) and those we are pursuing (as we write).
  3. Distinguish accurate and relevant information from inaccurate and irrelevant  information: in texts that we read and in preparation for our own writing.
  4. Reach logical inferences or conclusions: based on what we read, and in preparation for writing.
  5. Identify significant and deep concepts: those of an author and those we want to guide our thinking while we write.
  6. Distinguish justifiable from unjustifiable assumptions: that an author is using, or that we are using in our own thinking as we write.
  7. Trace logical implications: those of an author’s thinking, and those that may follow from our written work.
  8. Identify and think within multiple viewpoints: those that an author presents (or fails to present when relevant) and those relevant to the issues in our written work (and that we need to include).
Critical evaluation (phase) is the end product of the application of these elements.  The materials available at The Critical Thinking Community site (all for sale, some freely available) will provide the district or school with clear guides to improving student critical thinking.  If this is not an option, I recommend that all ELA teachers in the US should study the sample Critical Reading/Writing "text" - with anchor answers - for The Declaration of Independence (it is contained in the .pdf file).  This would be a great professional development or PLC activity.

Also of great use to ELA teachers are the following tools provided on The Critical Thinking Community site:
  • an overview of The Elements of Thought - an expansion of the pie above,
  • 35 Dimensions of Critical Thought,
  • remodeled lessons, which can be accessed through the navigation bar at the 35 Dimensions page (lessons reference the strategies) - I especially liked the remodeled Journal and Argumentative Writing lessons in the Junior High School section.
source
Simplification: All of this might be to complex for some teachers, however.  For these, a focus on Bloom's Taxonomy Revised (.pdf) is in order.  The top two tiers apply directly to critical evaluation:
  • Evaluating: Making judgments based on criteria and standards through checking and critiquing.
  • Creating: Putting elements together to form a coherent or functional whole; reorganizing elements into a new pattern or structure through generating, planning, or producing. 
The above explanation is from Mary Forehand - Bloom's Taxonomy.  Notice that producing is only one element of creating.  ELA teachers should not focus overly on creative projects or products - this emphasis is a flaw in most information about the Creating element.  Yes, it is the most fun part for students - the whole benefit of critical thinking is lost if the evaluative step is not embedded in the creative step.

For example, if the Essential Question for an ELA unit is the one I posed in my last post, Why are zombies compelling?  students might create a zombie movie as a culminating project.  Does this demonstrate critical understanding of the genre or the question?  Nope.  On the other hand, a video interview with the director, cast, and screenwriter of that imagined movie would be able to demonstrate a critical understanding of the question.

The key, therefore, is twofold (no surprises here, but reminders are in order):
  1. The texts must be worthy of critical evaluation - complex, challenging, accessible on multiple levels, question-raising
  2. The student tasks must (post-Analysis) address the Evaluating and Creating tiers of Blooms.  Paul and Elder strongly support the argument that the best of these tasks are also social in nature.  In other words, the culminating topic or assignment must be evaluative in nature. 
Conclusion: Which brings us back to ratings.  Critical shoppers ignore the overall rating and go directly to the reviews, which they read critically (Is there an agenda here? Does the review address the product? Does it provide me with real information? etc.).  Or goal is for students to always do the same.

Practical applications:
  • Taking a page from my Zombies unit, students could critically evaluate one of the texts by Brooks, a children's book, and one of the web texts - does it get better than that?
  • Detailed rubrics can provide students with some language for critical evaluation. Use them often and honestly, and insist that students read the evaluation text! Unfortunately, they are not readily available. 
  • It would be interesting to design a year-long critical evaluation focus with the thematic frame of Ratings Defended.  How would this be done?  Students would have to not only rate texts, responses to text (each other), models, etc. - they would be required to defend and explain each rating.  I can't think of a better use of:
I think this would eventually improve the whole value of social rating.  And I personally would begin as early as pre-K, where "thumbs up" is still a valid rating system. 

Resources to read and intrigue you:
  • Critical Thinking: Why is it so hard to teach?  (Daniel Willingham) (.pdf download)
  • Try this new widget - it is supposed to provide a critical thinking question every day (as well as to model the best forms of questioning):




Thursday, November 10, 2011

Writing/Thinking Smarter Tools: Beyond the Blueprint

source (not my cabin)
Jump down to the SCAN review.

I've just come in from inspecting a cabin we are building in the woods. The two young builders -  bright young guys who work for Morse and Doak - wanted to show us a problem area. Seems we have three walls on the 1-room central tower that a challenge to finish. One corner cantilevers out over the great room, one cantilevers out over the bedroom wing hall, and a 3rd continues the stairwell wall into the room.  What did we want to do to finish each so it doesn't grate visually against the other walls and spaces?  Great question.  I never knew it was a question until today.  I never thought about how many ways there are to finish a wall.  I never thought about how much math there is in building a frame cabin.  Granted, it is not a simple design.  When an "organic designer" draws up the plans, there are going to be complexities. 

"We have so many ideas," grinned Darius, "so many ways to solve the problems. A lot of crazy ideas just crashing around." As we discussed the ideas, he and Lonnie explained the pros and cons of each.  In the process, they had two or three more ideas.  The energy surging between the two ladders to the 2nd floor was palpable.  Their solutions were inventive, each firmly founded on knowledge of the topic (generally, boards and measurements) and the problem.  These weren't, in fact, crazy ideas at all.  What was crazy to Darius was the shear number of ideas he generated in response to the problem.   

I was lost.  I said, "I leave it up to you - just make what you are thinking and doing clear to me."  And they did, translating what they know into language I could follow, providing evidence to support the options they recommended, clarifying counter-proposals.  We made an action plan.

The experience got me thinking about thinking. All kids think - but isn't Darius and Lonnie-type thinking what we want kids to do?  Isn't this how we want our kids to approach learning problems?  Granted, my builders are highly trained and highly experienced. But they are also always thinking.  And they think smart - beyond the blueprint. 

ELA connection:  For the ELA classroom, the challenges focus mainly on thinking and writing about text and on the process of persuasion.

There are writing workshop models, writing curricula, reading workshop models, and reading curricula. But what it comes down to is this: You can not write well about anything unless you can think well about it.  And writing well carries a high premium - for both students and teachers.

It goes without saying, and is outside the scope of this post, that you can not think well about "it" if you can not read well about it.  Darius and Lonnie have skills I do not have: they can read blueprints and wood.  Presumably, our students come to us with the skills they need to access the information they need by reading.  Huge supposition - and often not true - but the essential question for this post is:  What can we do to help student DO something smarter with what they read?  Whether the challenge is to analyze or to persuade, What can we do to help them think?

Heather Wolpert-Gawron argues that all writing about text is persuasive writing.  I find this a clarifying idea. It means that all thinking about text - whether fictional or informational - is framed by the goal of persuasion.  It means that the essay can be re-imaged as a forum for convincing the reader.  This adds a vital dimension to writing - connection.  And connection leads to the need for: voice, style, evidence, explanation.  I have always known this to be true of good writing, but now I understand what makes it true.  My favorite motivational turn of phrase, Writing is problem-solving,  remains true also. The two concepts work hand-in-hand.

Read/Think then Write/Think.  You notice that in the above image Share is also embedded in the writing process. As my builders demonstrated, discussion extends and clarifies thinking. On the other hand, reading and idea-forming are highly individual activities. The best processes for writing require both individual and collaborative thought.

A last point.  It is essential that students push the write/think connection all the way to the level of what Randy Rambo calls The Warrant.  This is the step that involves explicitly making  the connection between the claim (point, opinion) and the evidence used to support it.  Some teachers call it the discussion or explanation.  I call it the So what? Why is this important?  Omitting this step is the most common flaw in middle and high school writing. The second most common flaw is insufficient or irrelevant evidence.  Most tools put a premium on having evidence, but few require students to evaluate it. Good, solid evidence-gathering is essential for any academic writing task.  Beginning as young as 1st grade, students should be asked to provide information to support their opinion statements.  Sloppy thinking habits begin with low expectations.  


The tools: Luckily, there are tools for education that help our kids to learn to think, to love new problems as much as Darius and Lonnie do, and to organize their thinking for writing.  Here is a short list of those I consider to be the best.

  • SCAN is a brand new online interactive tool for "arguing" - I think it is a powerful tool for thinking.  Imagine a RAFT activity that grows organically, one in which all of the roles interact OR in which one student can explore all of the roles.  I was so interested in this model that I created a SCAN session for teachers and students to use collaboratively.  Here is the link to Should We Cancel Halloween?   Please contribute - it is a public discussion. I believe that it is possible to use the SCAN tool to investigate a novel-based thesis.  You might, for example, explore violence, trust, or individual v. society in any dystopian novel.  Roles can be characters or roles can be points of view.  It seems to me this is a highly adaptable tool that ELA teachers should embrace.  I used the free tool; teachers and schools can get larger functionality by paying a reasonable subscription fee.
  • ReadWriteThink online tools include Persuasion Map and the Webbing Tool.  The webbing tool can easily be used to construct a paragraph or an essay.  Their Essay Map does not contain the warrant or discussion step, so don't use it.
  • Not all students think best in bubbles. Some prefer a linear or outline organizer.  Unfortunately, I could not find a solid organizer that includes the warrant.  I did find this neat little organizer that can be used for every claim and easily extended.   Students can also use the interactive Thesis Builder to begin the process of developing an outline. The outline generated by the tool can be used as a model for the creation of a blank paper outline.  It would be interesting to use this tool with a group. 
  • Practical idea for the classroom:  We all know what Word Walls are.  The Phrase Wall is a similar concept.  Few students have internalized the transition, connection, and rhetorical phrases that help them to truly write/think about and through a text.  Refer to the Wall when oral thinking is happening in the classroom.  A large visual of the phrases that can (and should) be used in writing is not a crutch - it is a necessity.  Add to the Wall as writing becomes more challenging. I find it most useful to put Phrase Wall phrases into categories:
    • ordering phrases - first, second, in conclusion - (not recommended for final drafts, but very useful when drafting - have students use them then take them out)
    • linking phrases - another, also, furthermore, in addition to...., moreover, etc.
    • change of direction phrases - however, on the other hand, but not, etc.
    • rebuttal phrases (specifically for "the nod to the opposition") - it can be argued that, evidence also points to..., etc.
    • idea starter phrases - consider..., an important/the most important..., etc.
    • evidence phrases - according to..., when [this happens]...[this happens], etc.  
    • warrant phrases - ______ is saying that, if this is true then..., this leads to..., by
    • comparing, as a result..., because..., etc.
    • conclusion phrases - it is clear that, clearly,  (these can also often be removed)
  • Thinking in the classroom: Activity tools.  Just talking is easy for adults, but not easy for children. It is a good idea to embed deeper thinking about a topic, text, or question in a short activity.  These activities are also valuable as stand-alones to develop thinking skills and language. Some ideas:
    • "body voting" followed by "build on someone" statements of opinion, evidence, or explanation
    • "fish bowl" discussions in which evidence must be presented and evaluated, discussed - here is a nice guide
    • "hot seat" in which evidence is used to question a character or role-player
    • "easel pad" discussions - evidence is displayed on large pages - groups move round the room adding explanation or discussion statements
    • "silent conversations" - small groups tackle a topic or thesis, not speaking but writing and adding to the point of the previous writer - can be done in roles 
    • Last point: In using any group tool, it is important to set the guideline that every student must participate.  No passes on thinking.